The client asks why the report says position 10 when Semrush says 25. Both numbers can be right. They answer different questions.
Should you trust Semrush or Google Search Console?
Trust Google Search Console for your own site: its clicks, impressions and average position are Google's own data for the properties you verify, and it is free. Trust Semrush for what Search Console cannot see: competitors, keywords you do not rank for yet, and search volume. Its rankings and traffic are estimates from its own database.
So use both: Search Console for what happened on the client's own site, Semrush for the market around it. Semrush gives the same advice in its own help center: "Use Google Search Console to measure your own website, and Semrush organic traffic to estimate other websites' traffic."
Semrush and Google pages checked on 18 November 2026What does Google Search Console measure?
Search Console is Google's free tool for site owners. It shows data only for the properties you verify, and Google defines its four main numbers this way:
- Clicks: "How often someone clicked a link from Google to your site."
- Impressions: "How often someone saw a link to your site on Google."
- CTR: clicks divided by impressions.
- Average position: the topmost position your link held in a result, averaged over all impressions. A link must get an impression for its position to be recorded.
Google says new data usually arrives in 2 to 3 days. The report keeps about 16 months of history. Rare queries are anonymized: they are left out of the tables but counted in the totals.
What does Semrush measure?
Semrush builds its own picture of Google from outside. Its data page (read 18 November 2026) lists, as of 2026, 142 geographic databases, 28.8 billion keywords, 808 million domains and 43 trillion backlinks.
- Rankings: Semrush works with third-party data providers to collect Google results pages for hundreds of millions of popular keywords and records the sites in the top 100 positions. Keywords refresh from once a day to once a month, depending on how popular they are.
- Traffic: Semrush "estimates organic traffic by multiplying a keyword's search volume by the estimated CTR of its ranking position". Its Traffic Analytics draws on a panel of over 200 million anonymized internet users, per the same data page.
- Position Tracking: a daily rank check for the keywords you choose, in one location and on one device, without personalization. Semrush says it updates every 24 to 48 hours.
Because none of this needs access to the site, Semrush works for any domain: a client, a competitor or a prospect you are pitching.
Semrush vs Search Console, side by side
| Google Search Console | Semrush | |
|---|---|---|
| Data source | Google's own data | Its own collection of results pages, plus a clickstream panel |
| Which sites | Only properties you verify | Any domain |
| Clicks | Actual clicks from Google | Estimated traffic: volume times expected CTR |
| Position | Average over all impressions, all locations and devices | One reading per keyword, for one location and device |
| Keywords | Queries you already get impressions for, minus anonymized ones | Its database of 28.8 billion keywords, including ones you do not rank for |
| Competitors and backlinks | Your own links only | Competitor keywords, traffic and backlinks |
| Freshness | Usually 2 to 3 days behind | Position Tracking every 24 to 48 hours |
| Price | Free | Free plan with limits; paid from €134 a month (shown to us in euros) |
Why do Semrush and Search Console show different positions?
Because a Search Console position is an average and a Semrush position is one reading. Five things pull them apart:
- Average vs snapshot. Search Console averages the topmost position over every impression in the date range. Semrush records one position per check.
- Everywhere vs one place. Search Console counts every country, device and searcher. Semrush Position Tracking checks one location and device you set, and Semrush says "different zip codes in the same city will serve different results".
- Personalization. Semrush shows unpersonalized results, and notes that Google personalizes by location, search history and language. Search Console counts what real people saw.
- Only when seen. Search Console records a position only when your link got an impression. A page that shows on a few searches at position 3 and never elsewhere averages 3.
- Dates. Search Console runs 2 to 3 days behind, and Semrush's database refreshes a keyword from daily to monthly by popularity, so the two often describe different days.
A one-day illustration, not a study: in a Patricia demo on 11 November 2026, one keyword sat at position 10 in Search Console and at position 25 in a third-party rank tracker, on the same day. One keyword, one day. It shows the size of gap that can appear, nothing more.

When is each one the better source?
Search Console is the better source for
- The clicks and impressions in a client report. They are Google's own counts.
- Pages with good positions and a low CTR, where a title rewrite is the fix.
- Long-tail queries a third-party database may not track.
- Indexing: whether Google has a page, and sitemap errors.
Semrush is the better source for
- Competitors: their keywords, estimated traffic and backlinks.
- Keywords you do not rank for yet, with search volume and difficulty.
- A fixed daily rank for one city or device, the way a local client checks it.
- A prospect's site, before you have access to their Search Console.
What does Semrush cost? (checked 18 November 2026)
Semrush shows prices in the visitor's currency. We read semrush.com/prices on 18 November 2026 and saw euros:
| Plan | Monthly | Billed yearly | What it includes, per Semrush |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free | $0 | n/a | 1 demo project, 10 reports a day |
| SEO | €134 | €112.52 a month | 5 websites, 500 keywords tracked daily, Position Tracking, Site Audit |
| Starter | €190 | €158.40 a month | 5 websites, 500 keywords daily, keyword research and competitor tools, 50 AI prompts tracked daily |
| Pro+ | €286 | €238 a month | 15 websites, 1,500 keywords daily, historical data |
| Advanced | On request | On request | 40+ websites, 5,000+ keywords daily, API data integration |
The page lists a 7-day free trial. API access is separate: Semrush's developer page (updated 13 November 2026) says its SEO API is for SEO Toolkit users with a Business subscription, and that API units are bought on top. Search Console costs nothing.
How to use both in a client report
- Lead with Search Console. Clicks, impressions, CTR and average position for the month, with the date range written next to them.
- Add Semrush for context. Competitor movement, new and lost backlinks, and keywords the client does not rank for yet.
- Never put the two positions in one column. Show the Search Console average and the tracked rank side by side, each labelled, and do not compute a difference.
- Explain gaps in one line. "Search Console averages every search; the tracker checks one city on one day."
Semrush can also import Search Console data itself: a Semrush blog post dated 11 November 2026 lists the SEO Dashboard, Position Tracking, Backlink Audit and My Reports as tools that connect to it. If you want the raw Search Console rows in a spreadsheet, see how to send Search Console data to Google Sheets.
Patricia: one report from both, in Slack or Teams
Patricia is an AI coworker for small agencies that works in Slack and Microsoft Teams. She reads Search Console and Semrush through connectors and joins them in one answer or one report.
- Search Console. Connects through Google's free API with one OAuth click per verified property, read-only: queries, clicks, impressions, CTR, position and indexing.
- Semrush. Connects to your own Semrush account. You need a Semrush subscription with API access; Patricia does not include Semrush data, and she only reads it.
- No Semrush? DataForSEO is built in, with nothing to connect, for rankings and backlinks. Each lookup is billed in credits at the provider's price.
- Rankings vs Search Console dashboard, in public beta. A dashboard template that puts a tracked rank next to the Search Console position for the top queries, labels both, and computes no difference, because they measure different things.
- What she does with it. Queries close to page one and worth a push, pages that rank but get few clicks, pages losing ground. See Semrush and Search Console together in Patricia.
- Where it stops. She reads the same numbers you would: Semrush's are still estimates, and Search Console's are still 2 to 3 days behind. Dashboards are in public beta. Briefs and client messages wait for a named yes by default.
- What it costs. $195 a month per workspace, every seat included, with 95,000 credits a month. Your Semrush subscription is separate.
Sources
- Semrush, read 18 November 2026: prices, Semrush data and metrics, how Semrush estimates organic traffic, Position Tracking differences, Semrush with Google Search Console, API access.
- Google, read 18 November 2026: Performance report metrics, About Search Console data, Performance data deep dive, Debugging search traffic drops.
- The 11 November 2026 example: one keyword in a Patricia demo, one day.
FAQ
Should I trust Semrush or Google Search Console?
Trust Google Search Console for your own site: its clicks, impressions and average position are Google's own data for the properties you verify, and it is free. Trust Semrush for what Search Console cannot see: competitors, keywords you do not rank for yet, and search volume. Its rankings and traffic are estimates from its own database.
Why is my Semrush position different from Search Console?
They measure different things. Search Console's average position is the topmost position of your link, averaged over every impression, across all countries, devices and searchers. Semrush Position Tracking checks one location and device without personalization, every 24 to 48 hours. A page can sit at 4 in one city and at 9 on average.
Is Semrush traffic accurate?
It is an estimate. Semrush says it estimates organic traffic by multiplying a keyword's search volume by the estimated click-through rate of its ranking position, and that it will not match Search Console, which reports actual clicks. Semrush's own advice is to use Search Console for your site and Semrush to estimate other sites.
Can Search Console show competitor data?
No. Search Console shows data only for the properties you verify. For a competitor's keywords, rankings or backlinks you need a third-party tool such as Semrush, Ahrefs or a data provider like DataForSEO.
How much does Semrush cost in 2026?
On 18 November 2026, semrush.com showed us a free plan, then SEO at €134 a month, Starter at €190 and Pro+ at €286, lower when billed yearly, and Advanced on request. Semrush has a 7-day free trial. Prices show in the visitor's currency, so check from your own country.
Does Semrush connect to Google Search Console?
Yes, in some tools. A Semrush blog post dated 11 November 2026 lists the SEO Dashboard, Position Tracking, Backlink Audit and My Reports as able to connect Search Console, and says Site Audit connects to Google Analytics only.
Can Patricia read both Semrush and Search Console?
Yes, through connectors, if you have both. Search Console connects through Google's free API. Semrush needs your own Semrush subscription with API access; Patricia does not include Semrush data. She costs $195 a month per workspace, every seat included.




